|
Post by geauxpokes1978 on Dec 20, 2023 8:24:40 GMT -6
In January it will be proposed to allow a onetime transfer for high school student athletes. Basically creating a transfer portal for the LHSAA I don't know how much steam this could pick up but if it does and somehow passes, could there be underlying ramifications for schools receiving students from out of zone? Maybe forcing those schools to be classified as a select school?
|
|
|
Post by brightlights on Dec 20, 2023 8:41:03 GMT -6
In January it will be proposed to allow a onetime transfer for high school student athletes. Basically creating a transfer portal for the LHSAA I don't know how much steam this could pick up but if it does and somehow passes, could there be underlying ramifications for schools receiving students from out of zone? Maybe forcing those schools to be classified as a select school? Good question. By the letter of the law on how select/non-select are written and defined now, any school that has the “ability” to accept out of zone students are classified as Select, whether they have any out of zone students or not. So, under those guidelines, every single school would have the ability to accept Out of zone, making every school select and essentially putting everyone back together.
|
|
|
Post by chalmetteowl on Dec 20, 2023 9:59:58 GMT -6
In January it will be proposed to allow a onetime transfer for high school student athletes. Basically creating a transfer portal for the LHSAA I don't know how much steam this could pick up but if it does and somehow passes, could there be underlying ramifications for schools receiving students from out of zone? Maybe forcing those schools to be classified as a select school? Yeah this isn’t gonna pass… I don’t think most of the membership is ready for this yet
|
|
ThePerks
All-District 2nd Team
Posts: 119
|
Post by ThePerks on Dec 21, 2023 7:47:38 GMT -6
In January it will be proposed to allow a onetime transfer for high school student athletes. Basically creating a transfer portal for the LHSAA I don't know how much steam this could pick up but if it does and somehow passes, could there be underlying ramifications for schools receiving students from out of zone? Maybe forcing those schools to be classified as a select school? Good question. By the letter of the law on how select/non-select are written and defined now, any school that has the “ability” to accept out of zone students are classified as Select, whether they have any out of zone students or not. So, under those guidelines, every single school would have the ability to accept Out of zone, making every school select and essentially putting everyone back together. Ooo, I like this! Great question and great response. And if it does pass at some point with limitations that still maintain select/non-select divisions, by some miraculous insertion of words in the definition, who will police this and maintain accurate records of each transaction? Will the principals have open access to view these records? I don’t think their current staff can handle this additional workload. So I don’t think we t will pass right now either. On a side note do the principals have open access to view the financials of the LHSAA?
|
|
|
Post by lsu88 on Dec 23, 2023 6:00:47 GMT -6
Oh for the love of god don’t do this to high school football.
|
|
|
Post by kbanes on Dec 23, 2023 18:03:17 GMT -6
I'm not really sure that anyone has thought about the ramifications of these on real world politics/education.
We have a split for select/non-select for political reasons, not athletic reasons. The Federal Government (with backing from teachers unions) is solely responsible for the organizational structure on our public educational systems. Their reason for how they do things is dependent on one thing, and that is ensuring that public school systems allow equal access to all students, as long as that access stays with the controlled boundaries of racial desegregation guidelines.
Public school systems require certain students to go to certain schools to ensure a balance of black/white students. All of the public schools that allow open enrollment (magnet schools) do so only to try to get students that are under represented at that school, to choose that school. Teachers unions don't fight private/charter schools because it causes inequalities in athletics success, they fight it because they lose control of the educational process.
Don't get me wrong. I am not arguing for or against how public school systems assign kids to certain schools. It is a job that I wouldn't want to be responsible for.
I just think that it is important, when we discuss/argue all things select/non-select, that we keep in mind that a lot of the reason for select public schools has nothing to do with athletics. It is a tool to drive diversity in a certain direction. And we all know how important diversity is.
kbanes
So, when there is a discussion of a one time transfer rule, I have to wonder how this would be possible, given the need to keep racial equality in scope. (Obviously this concern only applies to Public schools.)
|
|
cheezs
All-District 1st Team
Lafayette Christian
Posts: 257
|
Post by cheezs on Dec 26, 2023 10:44:16 GMT -6
make every school a select school and don't change the transfer rules.
|
|
ThePerks
All-District 2nd Team
Posts: 119
|
Post by ThePerks on Dec 26, 2023 17:49:37 GMT -6
make every school a select school and don't change the transfer rules. I believe that is right around the corner.
|
|
|
Post by chalmetteowl on Dec 26, 2023 20:13:35 GMT -6
make every school a select school and don't change the transfer rules. Not every school is select. Some have zones and they want to enforce them and couldn’t care less about whom they don’t get as a result
|
|
|
Post by walkingturtles on Dec 27, 2023 16:09:58 GMT -6
make every school a select school and don't change the transfer rules. Not every school is select. Some have zones and they want to enforce them and couldn’t care less about whom they don’t get as a result Let the kids and their parents decide where they want to go. It’s their lives.
|
|
|
Post by kbanes on Dec 27, 2023 22:22:02 GMT -6
Not every school is select. Some have zones and they want to enforce them and couldn’t care less about whom they don’t get as a result Let the kids and their parents decide where they want to go. It’s their lives. Thats impossible in a public school system.
|
|
cheezs
All-District 1st Team
Lafayette Christian
Posts: 257
|
Post by cheezs on Dec 27, 2023 22:40:52 GMT -6
Let the kids and their parents decide where they want to go. It’s their lives. Thats impossible in a public school system. 24 states require schools to have open enrollment for Public Schools.
|
|
|
Post by astrosnation on Jan 4, 2024 12:55:08 GMT -6
So what is on the agenda for LHSAA meeting in January?
|
|
|
Post by lhsaamemes on Jan 4, 2024 13:48:10 GMT -6
Let the kids and their parents decide where they want to go. It’s their lives. Thats impossible in a public school system. Attachments:
|
|
|
Post by chalmetteowl on Jan 4, 2024 18:56:39 GMT -6
Thats impossible in a public school system. 24 states require schools to have open enrollment for Public Schools. Louisiana will be one of the last… the legacy of racism is too deep
|
|
|
Post by walkingturtles on Jan 5, 2024 13:05:06 GMT -6
24 states require schools to have open enrollment for Public Schools. Louisiana will be one of the last… the legacy of racism is too deep The legacy of incompetence is too strong!!
|
|
|
Post by Rick James on Jan 6, 2024 16:20:48 GMT -6
So what is on the agenda for LHSAA meeting in January? Onetime Transfer: A student will have the option of a onetime transfer during his/her high school career. Exceptions; Bona Fide Move with his/her parents (as defined in 1.14). If the student has not used their onetime transfer option as defined, the following rules will apply: 1. A student entering high school for the first time who established his/her high school eligibility at a member school and subsequently transfers, will be ineligible for varsity competition for 365 days from the date of their transfer, in the sports in which they have been registered in and/or participated in during the previous 365 days from their date of enrollment. 2. The transfer rule addresses athletic eligibility only as it relates to transfers between schools. Rules related to age, semesters, academic requirements, and other LHSAA bylaws may results in an eligible transfer being declared ineligible. 3. Private school attendance boundaries will be defined, for admission purposes, by the public school in which the private school is physically located.
|
|
|
Post by lsu88 on Jan 11, 2024 21:30:48 GMT -6
So what is on the agenda for LHSAA meeting in January? Onetime Transfer: A student will have the option of a onetime transfer during his/her high school career. Exceptions; Bona Fide Move with his/her parents (as defined in 1.14). If the student has not used their onetime transfer option as defined, the following rules will apply: 1. A student entering high school for the first time who established his/her high school eligibility at a member school and subsequently transfers, will be ineligible for varsity competition for 365 days from the date of their transfer, in the sports in which they have been registered in and/or participated in during the previous 365 days from their date of enrollment. 2. The transfer rule addresses athletic eligibility only as it relates to transfers between schools. Rules related to age, semesters, academic requirements, and other LHSAA bylaws may results in an eligible transfer being declared ineligible. 3. Private school attendance boundaries will be defined, for admission purposes, by the public school in which the private school is physically located. Yea and one time eventually wouldn’t be enough because this or that happened and so on on and on. Just like college one time became not enough and now it’s a free for all.
|
|
|
Post by chalmetteowl on Jan 12, 2024 9:58:20 GMT -6
Onetime Transfer: A student will have the option of a onetime transfer during his/her high school career. Exceptions; Bona Fide Move with his/her parents (as defined in 1.14). If the student has not used their onetime transfer option as defined, the following rules will apply: 1. A student entering high school for the first time who established his/her high school eligibility at a member school and subsequently transfers, will be ineligible for varsity competition for 365 days from the date of their transfer, in the sports in which they have been registered in and/or participated in during the previous 365 days from their date of enrollment. 2. The transfer rule addresses athletic eligibility only as it relates to transfers between schools. Rules related to age, semesters, academic requirements, and other LHSAA bylaws may results in an eligible transfer being declared ineligible. 3. Private school attendance boundaries will be defined, for admission purposes, by the public school in which the private school is physically located. Yea and one time eventually wouldn’t be enough because this or that happened and so on on and on. Just like college one time became not enough and now it’s a free for all. what would cause all bets to be off would be a court decision where student athletes below 18 years old would be subject to all the rules of the LHSAA as they are currently, but those over 18 would be legal adults and basically have the same rights as college athletes with the right to transfer wherever and the right to get NIL
|
|
|
Post by lhsaamemes on Jan 12, 2024 10:27:05 GMT -6
Yea and one time eventually wouldn’t be enough because this or that happened and so on on and on. Just like college one time became not enough and now it’s a free for all. what would cause all bets to be off would be a court decision where student athletes below 18 years old would be subject to all the rules of the LHSAA as they are currently, but those over 18 would be legal adults and basically have the same rights as college athletes with the right to transfer wherever and the right to get NIL Attachments:
|
|
|
Post by mt on Jan 25, 2024 11:32:36 GMT -6
Didn’t even make it to vote
|
|
|
Post by fanman on Jan 29, 2024 8:43:57 GMT -6
I say don’t to this it will create so much confusion and more than likely money buying of players
|
|
|
Post by lhsaamemes on Jan 29, 2024 9:28:50 GMT -6
I say don’t to this it will create so much confusion and more than likely money buying of players Attachments:
|
|