Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 18, 2016 8:06:13 GMT -6
Then I don't believe there is a difference, had his legal guardian (not aunt, grandma, close friend) moved to Welsh/Kinder then he would be eligible at those schools. The difference in the two is that even had he not moved from his previous house he could still attend ND but would have to sit out a year (I think he would have to sit not 100% sure), however he could not enroll at Kinder/Welsh, because he does not live in their zone. Thats the argument between select/non-select, where can they get their kids. Seriously? What did you coach, beer pong? He transferred as a jr after the football season. He couldn't sit out a year anywhere and be eligible. He had to move, and could have moved anywhere he wanted to, including Kinder., First off I dont what grade the kid is in, all I know theres an uproar because he plays at ND and didnt last year. Now on to the second part of my statement, had Tim Thompson a stud freshman WR who lives in Iowa, LA and attends Iowa High decides he want to play for ND all he has to do is drive 40 miles down the road (drive right by Welsh High School) and enroll at ND, walk the halls, join the FB team and exactly 1 year from today be eligible. And he could do this while living in Iowa and never move. If Tim wanted to leave Iowa High school, but still live in Iowa, and go enroll and play at Welsh he would have to...well never mind he cant enroll in Welsh because he lives out of district. Thats why there is a split....not the same rules. Please tell me how this fair to Welsh. Now does the guy at ND, who is a Senior in case anyone didnt know that, pay tuition or is he on scholarship, financial aid, etc?
|
|
|
Post by indy on Nov 18, 2016 8:18:44 GMT -6
Seriously? What did you coach, beer pong? He transferred as a jr after the football season. He couldn't sit out a year anywhere and be eligible. He had to move, and could have moved anywhere he wanted to, including Kinder., First off I dont what grade the kid is in, all I know theres an uproar because he plays at ND and didnt last year. Now on to the second part of my statement, had Tim Thompson a stud freshman WR who lives in Iowa, LA and attends Iowa High decides he want to play for ND all he has to do is drive 40 miles down the road (drive right by Welsh High School) and enroll at ND, walk the halls, join the FB team and exactly 1 year from today be eligible. And he could do this while living in Iowa and never move. If Tim wanted to leave Iowa High school, but still live in Iowa, and go enroll and play at Welsh he would have to...well never mind he cant enroll in Welsh because he lives out of district. Thats why there is a split....not the same rules. Please tell me how this fair to Welsh. Now does the guy at ND, who is a Senior in case anyone didnt know that, pay tuition or is he on scholarship, financial aid, etc? We have no scholarships. His family pays like everybody else. Your sob story about Iowa should be true, but you know and I know there are ways to skirt the system and they do. How many kids from Laccasine, Bell City, or Fenton play at Iowa? Travis Etienne lives in Welsh but simply uses is grandmothers Jennings adress. So the rules are different, but not followed.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 18, 2016 8:27:48 GMT -6
I have no idea how many kids from Laccisne, Bell City, or Fenton play at Iowa. If rules arent being followed then the LHSAA needs to investigate all situations like this. Maybe this is step one to getting things fixed.
However bottom line is Tim could openly tell people he lives in Iowa and attends ND, and he doesnt have to skirt the system, find a loophole and still live outside the district and attend another school 40 miles away. You cant (according to the LHSAA bylaws) do this with a public school, because then the school and student are punished and/or fined. Once again how is this fair?
|
|
|
Post by indy on Nov 18, 2016 8:52:53 GMT -6
I have no idea how many kids from Laccisne, Bell City, or Fenton play at Iowa. If rules arent being followed then the LHSAA needs to investigate all situations like this. Maybe this is step one to getting things fixed. However bottom line is Tim could openly tell people he lives in Iowa and attends ND, and he doesnt have to skirt the system, find a loophole and still live outside the district and attend another school 40 miles away. You cant (according to the LHSAA bylaws) do this with a public school, because then the school and student are punished and/or fined. Once again how is this fair? The LHSAA is a joke, But it's Friday so I'm off!
|
|
|
Post by cenlaman on Nov 18, 2016 9:01:10 GMT -6
Many is happy with being below average. They r scared of competition. LMAO I've seen Calvary on film. I've seen Many in person twice. I can assure you that they are neither below average or afraid of competition. They would score 60 on Calvary's defense.
|
|
|
Post by cenlaman on Nov 18, 2016 9:06:09 GMT -6
Shelvin doesn't have to pay tuition at ND. LSU is taking care of that through other channels.
Crowley wasn't his first move when he left Lafayette. Crowley was the second move in order to make things look more legit.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 18, 2016 9:14:50 GMT -6
Many is happy with being below average. They r scared of competition. LMAO I've seen Calvary on film. I've seen Many in person twice. I can assure you that they are neither below average or afraid of competition. They would score 60 on Calvary's defense. dont disagree with that have Many call us we love the challenge. . If theyre not scared. They run from competition. That's why they play on the JV side of the bracket. LOL
|
|
|
Post by Raven on Nov 18, 2016 10:59:38 GMT -6
I have no idea how many kids from Laccisne, Bell City, or Fenton play at Iowa. If rules arent being followed then the LHSAA needs to investigate all situations like this. Maybe this is step one to getting things fixed. However bottom line is Tim could openly tell people he lives in Iowa and attends ND, and he doesnt have to skirt the system, find a loophole and still live outside the district and attend another school 40 miles away. You cant (according to the LHSAA bylaws) do this with a public school, because then the school and student are punished and/or fined. Once again how is this fair? While it is true that student who live in other zones are able to attend Notre Dame that doesn't mean they all have the desire or the means to do so. Not all students want to adhere to the stricter codes of discipline or dress codes at a Catholic school. Not everyone can meet the (sometimes) tougher academic requirements. And most importantly, not everyone wants to shell out 6-7 grand every year to send their kids to school. And that's just for 1 kid. If you have 3 or more then you're talking at least 15-20 thousand dollars every year. That's not for everyone. On the other hand, public schools are guaranteed a certain amount of students each year based on the zones set up by their local school boards. Regardless of how good or bad that school may be. Another question I ask is that if a student wants to attend and play for another school's team, why would you want that student to remain on your team? Even the most talented players aren't going to perform when their heart isn't in it. Unless you subscribe to the theory that ALL students are automatically the property of their local public school and no other school has a right to that student regardless of the wishes of that student or his parents. I think this attitude is prevalent in the minds of most of the public school principles that voted in favor of the split. There are a number of kids in the northern part Iberville Parish in the Gross Tete/Rosedale/Maringouin area that are zoned to attend Plaquemine High (since North Iberville was closed back in 2008) but somehow they go to Livonia (Pointe Coupee Parish) instead. Granted it is closer so I don't blame them for wanting to go there, but it serves to illustrate how easy it is to get around attendance zone rules.
|
|
|
Post by sportsdude on Nov 18, 2016 13:20:03 GMT -6
Well just want to say I was picking the games and saw Scotlandville in the non-select power ratings and that is how this craziness started.....lol
|
|
|
Post by iknownuthing on Nov 21, 2016 9:33:08 GMT -6
Shelvin doesn't have to pay tuition at ND. LSU is taking care of that through other channels. Crowley wasn't his first move when he left Lafayette. Crowley was the second move in order to make things look more legit. So you are saying that not only does Notre Dame and all other Private Schools by association cheat, but that LSU the "Flagship" university in this state, not only is cheating to get a player by paying his tuition to a private school a violation of the NCAA no contact rules and the NCAA undue influence rule, with a lack of institutional control, but that they are also committing: Fraud, misappropriation of funds, Conspiracy to commit fraud and several other FEDERAL and STATE violations of Law as institutional FELONS?
|
|
|
Post by btown on Nov 21, 2016 10:29:15 GMT -6
Where do we order our soap? Lol
|
|
|
Post by iknownuthing on Nov 21, 2016 12:59:25 GMT -6
|
|
|
Post by btown on Nov 21, 2016 13:23:36 GMT -6
Just figured that since we have beat that horse to death we should have soap.
|
|
|
Post by pinion on Nov 22, 2016 12:04:32 GMT -6
Just figured that since we have beat that horse to death we should have soap. Well, your side of the fence lied and whined about things for 20+ years... You didn't seem to have an issue with beating that horse...
|
|
|
Post by btown on Nov 22, 2016 16:20:38 GMT -6
Just figured that since we have beat that horse to death we should have soap. Well, your side of the fence lied and whined about things for 20+ years... You didn't seem to have an issue with beating that horse... I never whined the past 20+ years, so find yourself another goat.
|
|
|
Post by pinion on Nov 22, 2016 20:05:03 GMT -6
Well, your side of the fence lied and whined about things for 20+ years... You didn't seem to have an issue with beating that horse... I never whined the past 20+ years, so find yourself another goat. That's why I said "your side of the fence" and not "you".
|
|
|
Post by cenlaman on Nov 23, 2016 12:26:32 GMT -6
Shelvin doesn't have to pay tuition at ND. LSU is taking care of that through other channels. Crowley wasn't his first move when he left Lafayette. Crowley was the second move in order to make things look more legit. So you are saying that not only does Notre Dame and all other Private Schools by association cheat, but that LSU the "Flagship" university in this state, not only is cheating to get a player by paying his tuition to a private school a violation of the NCAA no contact rules and the NCAA undue influence rule, with a lack of institutional control, but that they are also committing: Fraud, misappropriation of funds, Conspiracy to commit fraud and several other FEDERAL and STATE violations of Law as institutional FELONS? [ You catch your breath yet? You are easily amused, aren't you?
|
|